Shared versus Owned Objects
Objects on Sui can be shared (accessible for reads and writes by any transaction) or owned (accessible for reads and writes by transactions signed by their owner). Many applications can be built using a solution that either uses shared objects or only owned objects, with trade-offs for each that need to be weighed.
Transactions that use only owned objects benefit from very low latency to finality, because they do not need to go through consensus. On the other hand, the fact that only the owner of the object can access it complicates processes that need to work with objects owned by multiple parties, and access to very hot objects needs to be coordinated off-chain.
Transactions that access one or more shared objects require consensus to sequence reads and writes to those objects, resulting in a slightly higher gas cost and increased latency.
Transactions that access multiple shared objects, or particularly popular objects, might have increases in latency due to contention. However, the advantage of using shared objects lies in the flexibility of allowing multiple addresses to access the same object in a coordinated manner.
To summarize, applications that are extremely sensitive to latency or gas costs, that do not need to handle complex multi-party transactions, or that already require an off-chain service could benefit from a design that only uses owned objects. Applications that require coordination between multiple parties typically benefit from using shared objects.
For more information on the types of objects that Sui supports, see Object Ownership.
Example: Escrow
The Escrow example demonstrates the trade-offs between shared objects and owned objects by implementing the same application in both styles. It implements a service that allows two addresses to perform a trustless swap of objects with each other (a "trade") with the service holding their objects in escrow.
Locked<T> and Key
Both implementations use a primitive for locking values, which offers the following interface:
module escrow::lock {
public fun lock<T: store>(obj: T, ctx: &mut TxContext): (Locked<T>, Key);
public fun unlock<T: store>(locked: Locked<T>, key: Key): T
}
Any T: store can be locked, to get a Locked<T> and a corresponding Key, and conversely, the locked value and its corresponding key can be consumed to get back the wrapped object.
The important property that this interface provides is that locked values cannot be modified except by unlocking them first (and later relocking them). Because unlocking consumes the key, tampering with a locked value can be detected by remembering the ID of the key that it was locked with. This prevents situations where one party in a swap changes the object they are offering to reduce its value.
Owned objects
Toggle code sample
/// An escrow for atomic swap of objects using single-owner transactions that
/// trusts a third party for liveness, but not safety.
///
/// Swap via Escrow proceeds in three phases:
///
/// 1. Both parties `lock` their objects, getting the `Locked` object and a
/// `Key`. Each party can `unlock` their object, to preserve liveness if the
/// other party stalls before completing the second stage.
///
/// 2. Both parties register an `Escrow` object with the custodian, this
/// requires passing the locked object and its key. The key is consumed to
/// unlock the object, but its ID is remembered so the custodian can ensure
/// the right objects being swapped. The custodian is trusted to preserve
/// liveness.
///
/// 3. The custodian swaps the locked objects as long as all conditions are met:
///
/// - The sender of one Escrow is the recipient of the other and vice versa.
/// If this is not true, the custodian has incorrectly paired together this
/// swap.
///
/// - The key of the desired object (`exchange_key`) matches the key the
/// other object was locked with (`escrowed_key`) and vice versa.
/// If this is not true, it means the wrong objects are being swapped,
/// either because the custodian paired the wrong escrows together, or
/// because one of the parties tampered with their object after locking it.
///
/// The key in question is the ID of the `Key` object that unlocked the
/// `Locked` object that the respective objects resided in immediately
/// before being sent to the custodian.
module escrow::owned {
use escrow::lock::{Self, Locked, Key};
/// An object held in escrow
public struct Escrow<T: key + store> has key {
id: UID,
/// Owner of `escrowed`
sender: address,
/// Intended recipient
recipient: address,
/// The ID of the key that opens the lock on the object sender wants
/// from recipient.
exchange_key: ID,
/// The ID of the key that locked the escrowed object, before it was
/// escrowed.
escrowed_key: ID,
/// The escrowed object.
escrowed: T,
}
// === Error codes ===
/// The `sender` and `recipient` of the two escrowed objects do not match
const EMismatchedSenderRecipient: u64 = 0;
/// The `exchange_key` fields of the two escrowed objects do not match
const EMismatchedExchangeObject: u64 = 1;
// === Public Functions ===
/// `ctx.sender()` requests a swap with `recipient` of a locked
/// object `locked` in exchange for an object referred to by `exchange_key`.
/// The swap is performed by a third-party, `custodian`, that is trusted to
/// maintain liveness, but not safety (the only actions they can perform are
/// to successfully progress the swap).
///
/// `locked` will be unlocked with its corresponding `key` before being sent
/// to the custodian, but the underlying object is still not accessible
/// until after the swap has executed successfully, or the custodian returns
/// the object.
///
/// `exchange_key` is the ID of a `Key` that unlocks the sender's desired
/// object. Gating the swap on the key ensures that it will not succeed if
/// the desired object is tampered with after the sender's object is held in
/// escrow, because the recipient would have to consume the key to tamper
/// with the object, and if they re-locked the object it would be protected
/// by a different, incompatible key.
public fun create<T: key + store>(
key: Key,
locked: Locked<T>,
exchange_key: ID,
recipient: address,
custodian: address,
ctx: &mut TxContext,
) {
let escrow = Escrow {
id: object::new(ctx),
sender: ctx.sender(),
recipient,
exchange_key,
escrowed_key: object::id(&key),
escrowed: locked.unlock(key),
};
transfer::transfer(escrow, custodian);
}
/// Function for custodian (trusted third-party) to perform a swap between
/// two parties. Fails if their senders and recipients do not match, or if
/// their respective desired objects do not match.
public fun swap<T: key + store, U: key + store>(
obj1: Escrow<T>,
obj2: Escrow<U>,
) {
let Escrow {
id: id1,
sender: sender1,
recipient: recipient1,
exchange_key: exchange_key1,
escrowed_key: escrowed_key1,
escrowed: escrowed1,
} = obj1;
let Escrow {
id: id2,
sender: sender2,
recipient: recipient2,
exchange_key: exchange_key2,
escrowed_key: escrowed_key2,
escrowed: escrowed2,
} = obj2;
id1.delete();
id2.delete();
// Make sure the sender and recipient match each other
assert!(sender1 == recipient2, EMismatchedSenderRecipient);
assert!(sender2 == recipient1, EMismatchedSenderRecipient);
// Make sure the objects match each other and haven't been modified
// (they remain locked).
assert!(escrowed_key1 == exchange_key2, EMismatchedExchangeObject);
assert!(escrowed_key2 == exchange_key1, EMismatchedExchangeObject);
// Do the actual swap
transfer::public_transfer(escrowed1, recipient1);
transfer::public_transfer(escrowed2, recipient2);
}
/// The custodian can always return an escrowed object to its original
/// owner.
public fun return_to_sender<T: key + store>(obj: Escrow<T>) {
let Escrow {
id,
sender,
recipient: _,
exchange_key: _,
escrowed_key: _,
escrowed,
} = obj;
id.delete();
transfer::public_transfer(escrowed, sender);
}
// === Tests ===
#[test_only] use sui::coin::{Self, Coin};
#[test_only] use sui::sui::SUI;
#[test_only] use sui::test_scenario::{Self as ts, Scenario};
#[test_only] const ALICE: address = @0xA;
#[test_only] const BOB: address = @0xB;
#[test_only] const CUSTODIAN: address = @0xC;
#[test_only] const DIANE: address = @0xD;
#[test_only]
fun test_coin(ts: &mut Scenario): Coin<SUI> {
coin::mint_for_testing<SUI>(42, ts::ctx(ts))
}
#[test]
fun test_successful_swap() {
let mut ts = ts::begin(@0x0);
// Alice locks the object they want to trade
let (i1, ik1) = {
ts.next_tx(ALICE);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
let cid = object::id(&c);
let (l, k) = lock::lock(c, ts.ctx());
let kid = object::id(&k);
transfer::public_transfer(l, ALICE);
transfer::public_transfer(k, ALICE);
(cid, kid)
};
// Bob locks their object as well.
let (i2, ik2) = {
ts.next_tx(BOB);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
let cid = object::id(&c);
let (l, k) = lock::lock(c, ts.ctx());
let kid = object::id(&k);
transfer::public_transfer(l, BOB);
transfer::public_transfer(k, BOB);
(cid, kid)
};
// Alice gives the custodian their object to hold in escrow.
{
ts.next_tx(ALICE);
let k1: Key = ts.take_from_sender();
let l1: Locked<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_from_sender();
create(k1, l1, ik2, BOB, CUSTODIAN, ts.ctx());
};
// Bob does the same.
{
ts.next_tx(BOB);
let k2: Key = ts.take_from_sender();
let l2: Locked<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_from_sender();
create(k2, l2, ik1, ALICE, CUSTODIAN, ts.ctx());
};
// The custodian makes the swap
{
ts.next_tx(CUSTODIAN);
swap<Coin<SUI>, Coin<SUI>>(
ts.take_from_sender(),
ts.take_from_sender(),
);
};
// Commit effects from the swap
ts.next_tx(@0x0);
// Alice gets the object from Bob
{
let c: Coin<SUI> = ts.take_from_address_by_id(ALICE, i2);
ts::return_to_address(ALICE, c);
};
// Bob gets the object from Alice
{
let c: Coin<SUI> = ts.take_from_address_by_id(BOB, i1);
ts::return_to_address(BOB, c);
};
ts.end();
}
#[test]
#[expected_failure(abort_code = EMismatchedSenderRecipient)]
fun test_mismatch_sender() {
let mut ts = ts::begin(@0x0);
let ik1 = {
ts.next_tx(ALICE);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
let (l, k) = lock::lock(c, ts.ctx());
let kid = object::id(&k);
transfer::public_transfer(l, ALICE);
transfer::public_transfer(k, ALICE);
kid
};
let ik2 = {
ts.next_tx(BOB);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
let (l, k) = lock::lock(c, ts.ctx());
let kid = object::id(&k);
transfer::public_transfer(l, BOB);
transfer::public_transfer(k, BOB);
kid
};
// Alice wants to trade with Bob.
{
ts.next_tx(ALICE);
let k1: Key = ts.take_from_sender();
let l1: Locked<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_from_sender();
create(k1, l1, ik2, BOB, CUSTODIAN, ts.ctx());
};
// But Bob wants to trade with Diane.
{
ts.next_tx(BOB);
let k2: Key = ts.take_from_sender();
let l2: Locked<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_from_sender();
create(k2, l2, ik1, DIANE, CUSTODIAN, ts.ctx());
};
// When the custodian tries to match up the swap, it will fail.
{
ts.next_tx(CUSTODIAN);
swap<Coin<SUI>, Coin<SUI>>(
ts.take_from_sender(),
ts.take_from_sender(),
);
};
abort 1337
}
#[test]
#[expected_failure(abort_code = EMismatchedExchangeObject)]
fun test_mismatch_object() {
let mut ts = ts::begin(@0x0);
let ik1 = {
ts.next_tx(ALICE);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
let (l, k) = lock::lock(c, ts.ctx());
let kid = object::id(&k);
transfer::public_transfer(l, ALICE);
transfer::public_transfer(k, ALICE);
kid
};
{
ts.next_tx(BOB);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
let (l, k) = lock::lock(c, ts.ctx());
transfer::public_transfer(l, BOB);
transfer::public_transfer(k, BOB);
};
// Alice wants to trade with Bob, but Alice has asked for an
// object (via its `exchange_key`) that Bob has not put up for
// the swap.
{
ts.next_tx(ALICE);
let k1: Key = ts.take_from_sender();
let l1: Locked<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_from_sender();
create(k1, l1, ik1, BOB, CUSTODIAN, ts.ctx());
};
{
ts.next_tx(BOB);
let k2: Key = ts.take_from_sender();
let l2: Locked<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_from_sender();
create(k2, l2, ik1, ALICE, CUSTODIAN, ts.ctx());
};
// When the custodian tries to match up the swap, it will fail.
{
ts.next_tx(CUSTODIAN);
swap<Coin<SUI>, Coin<SUI>>(
ts.take_from_sender(),
ts.take_from_sender()
);
};
abort 1337
}
#[test]
#[expected_failure(abort_code = EMismatchedExchangeObject)]
fun test_object_tamper() {
let mut ts = ts::begin(@0x0);
// Alice locks the object they want to trade
let ik1 = {
ts.next_tx(ALICE);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
let (l, k) = lock::lock(c, ts.ctx());
let kid = object::id(&k);
transfer::public_transfer(l, ALICE);
transfer::public_transfer(k, ALICE);
kid
};
// Bob locks their object as well.
let ik2 = {
ts.next_tx(BOB);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
let (l, k) = lock::lock(c, ts.ctx());
let kid = object::id(&k);
transfer::public_transfer(l, BOB);
transfer::public_transfer(k, BOB);
kid
};
// Alice gives the custodian their object to hold in escrow.
{
ts.next_tx(ALICE);
let k1: Key = ts.take_from_sender();
let l1: Locked<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_from_sender();
create(k1, l1, ik2, BOB, CUSTODIAN, ts.ctx());
};
// Bob has a change of heart, so they unlock the object and tamper
// with it.
{
ts.next_tx(BOB);
let k: Key = ts.take_from_sender();
let l: Locked<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_from_sender();
let mut c = lock::unlock(l, k);
let _dust = coin::split(&mut c, 1, ts.ctx());
let (l, k) = lock::lock(c, ts.ctx());
create(k, l, ik1, ALICE, CUSTODIAN, ts.ctx());
};
// When the Custodian makes the swap, it detects Bob's nefarious
// behaviour.
{
ts.next_tx(CUSTODIAN);
swap<Coin<SUI>, Coin<SUI>>(
ts.take_from_sender(),
ts.take_from_sender(),
);
};
abort 1337
}
#[test]
fun test_return_to_sender() {
let mut ts = ts::begin(@0x0);
// Alice locks the object they want to trade
let cid = {
ts.next_tx(ALICE);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
let cid = object::id(&c);
let (l, k) = lock::lock(c, ts.ctx());
let i = object::id_from_address(@0x0);
create(k, l, i, BOB, CUSTODIAN, ts.ctx());
cid
};
// Custodian sends it back
{
ts.next_tx(CUSTODIAN);
return_to_sender<Coin<SUI>>(ts.take_from_sender());
};
ts.next_tx(@0x0);
// Alice can then access it.
{
let c: Coin<SUI> = ts.take_from_address_by_id(ALICE, cid);
ts::return_to_address(ALICE, c)
};
ts.end();
}
}
The protocol for swapping via escrow implemented using owned objects starts with both parties locking their respective objects.
This is used to prove that the object has not been tampered with after the swap has been agreed to. If either party doesn't want to proceed at this stage, they just unlock their object.
Assuming both parties are happy to continue, the next step requires both parties to swap the keys.
A third party acts as custodian. The custodian holds objects that are waiting for their counterparts to arrive and when they arrive, it matches them up to complete the swap.
public fun create<T: key + store>(
key: Key,
locked: Locked<T>,
exchange_key: ID,
recipient: address,
custodian: address,
ctx: &mut TxContext,
) {
let escrow = Escrow {
id: object::new(ctx),
sender: ctx.sender(),
recipient,
exchange_key,
escrowed_key: object::id(&key),
escrowed: locked.unlock(key),
};
transfer::transfer(escrow, custodian);
}
The create function prepares the Escrow request and sends it to the custodian. The object being offered by this party is passed in, locked, with its key, and the object being requested is identified by the ID of the key it was locked with. While preparing the request, the offered object is unlocked, while remembering the ID of its key.
Although the custodian is trusted to preserve liveness (to complete swaps if it owns both sides of a swap and to return objects if requested), all other correctness properties are maintained in Move: Even though the custodian owns both objects being swapped, the only valid action they are permitted to take is to match them up with their correct counterpart to finish the swap, or to return them:
/// Function for custodian (trusted third-party) to perform a swap between
/// two parties. Fails if their senders and recipients do not match, or if
/// their respective desired objects do not match.
public fun swap<T: key + store, U: key + store>(
obj1: Escrow<T>,
obj2: Escrow<U>,
) {
let Escrow {
id: id1,
sender: sender1,
recipient: recipient1,
exchange_key: exchange_key1,
escrowed_key: escrowed_key1,
escrowed: escrowed1,
} = obj1;
let Escrow {
id: id2,
sender: sender2,
recipient: recipient2,
exchange_key: exchange_key2,
escrowed_key: escrowed_key2,
escrowed: escrowed2,
} = obj2;
id1.delete();
id2.delete();
// Make sure the sender and recipient match each other
assert!(sender1 == recipient2, EMismatchedSenderRecipient);
assert!(sender2 == recipient1, EMismatchedSenderRecipient);
// Make sure the objects match each other and haven't been modified
// (they remain locked).
assert!(escrowed_key1 == exchange_key2, EMismatchedExchangeObject);
assert!(escrowed_key2 == exchange_key1, EMismatchedExchangeObject);
// Do the actual swap
transfer::public_transfer(escrowed1, recipient1);
transfer::public_transfer(escrowed2, recipient2);
}
The swap function checks that senders and recipients match and that each party wants the object that the other party is offering, by comparing their respective key IDs. If the custodian tried to match together two unrelated escrow requests to swap, the transaction would not succeed.
Shared objects
Toggle code sample
/// An escrow for atomic swap of objects using shared objects without a trusted
/// third party.
///
/// The protocol consists of three phases:
///
/// 1. One party `lock`s their object, getting a `Locked` object and its `Key`.
/// This party can `unlock` their object to preserve livness if the other
/// party stalls before completing the second stage.
///
/// 2. The other party registers a publicly accessible, shared `Escrow` object.
/// This effectively locks their object at a particular version as well,
/// waiting for the first party to complete the swap. The second party is
/// able to request their object is returned to them, to preserve liveness as
/// well.
///
/// 3. The first party sends their locked object and its key to the shared
/// `Escrow` object. This completes the swap, as long as all conditions are
/// met:
///
/// - The sender of the swap transaction is the recipient of the `Escrow`.
///
/// - The key of the desired object (`exchange_key`) in the escrow matches
/// the key supplied in the swap.
///
/// - The key supplied in the swap unlocks the `Locked<U>`.
module escrow::shared {
use sui::{
event,
dynamic_object_field::{Self as dof}
};
use escrow::lock::{Self, Locked, Key};
/// The `name` of the DOF that holds the Escrowed object.
/// Allows easy discoverability for the escrowed object.
public struct EscrowedObjectKey has copy, store, drop {}
/// An object held in escrow
///
/// The escrowed object is added as a Dynamic Object Field so it can still be looked-up.
public struct Escrow<phantom T: key + store> has key, store {
id: UID,
/// Owner of `escrowed`
sender: address,
/// Intended recipient
recipient: address,
/// ID of the key that opens the lock on the object sender wants from
/// recipient.
exchange_key: ID,
}
// === Error codes ===
/// The `sender` and `recipient` of the two escrowed objects do not match
const EMismatchedSenderRecipient: u64 = 0;
/// The `exchange_for` fields of the two escrowed objects do not match
const EMismatchedExchangeObject: u64 = 1;
// === Public Functions ===
public fun create<T: key + store>(
escrowed: T,
exchange_key: ID,
recipient: address,
ctx: &mut TxContext
) {
let mut escrow = Escrow<T> {
id: object::new(ctx),
sender: ctx.sender(),
recipient,
exchange_key,
};
event::emit(EscrowCreated {
escrow_id: object::id(&escrow),
key_id: exchange_key,
sender: escrow.sender,
recipient,
item_id: object::id(&escrowed),
});
dof::add(&mut escrow.id, EscrowedObjectKey {}, escrowed);
transfer::public_share_object(escrow);
}
/// The `recipient` of the escrow can exchange `obj` with the escrowed item
public fun swap<T: key + store, U: key + store>(
mut escrow: Escrow<T>,
key: Key,
locked: Locked<U>,
ctx: &TxContext,
): T {
let escrowed = dof::remove<EscrowedObjectKey, T>(&mut escrow.id, EscrowedObjectKey {});
let Escrow {
id,
sender,
recipient,
exchange_key,
} = escrow;
assert!(recipient == ctx.sender(), EMismatchedSenderRecipient);
assert!(exchange_key == object::id(&key), EMismatchedExchangeObject);
// Do the actual swap
transfer::public_transfer(locked.unlock(key), sender);
event::emit(EscrowSwapped {
escrow_id: id.to_inner(),
});
id.delete();
escrowed
}
/// The `creator` can cancel the escrow and get back the escrowed item
public fun return_to_sender<T: key + store>(
mut escrow: Escrow<T>,
ctx: &TxContext
): T {
event::emit(EscrowCancelled {
escrow_id: object::id(&escrow)
});
let escrowed = dof::remove<EscrowedObjectKey, T>(&mut escrow.id, EscrowedObjectKey {});
let Escrow {
id,
sender,
recipient: _,
exchange_key: _,
} = escrow;
assert!(sender == ctx.sender(), EMismatchedSenderRecipient);
id.delete();
escrowed
}
// === Events ===
public struct EscrowCreated has copy, drop {
/// the ID of the escrow that was created
escrow_id: ID,
/// The ID of the `Key` that unlocks the requested object.
key_id: ID,
/// The id of the sender who'll receive `T` upon swap
sender: address,
/// The (original) recipient of the escrowed object
recipient: address,
/// The ID of the escrowed item
item_id: ID,
}
public struct EscrowSwapped has copy, drop {
escrow_id: ID
}
public struct EscrowCancelled has copy, drop {
escrow_id: ID
}
// === Tests ===
#[test_only] use sui::coin::{Self, Coin};
#[test_only] use sui::sui::SUI;
#[test_only] use sui::test_scenario::{Self as ts, Scenario};
#[test_only] const ALICE: address = @0xA;
#[test_only] const BOB: address = @0xB;
#[test_only] const DIANE: address = @0xD;
#[test_only]
fun test_coin(ts: &mut Scenario): Coin<SUI> {
coin::mint_for_testing<SUI>(42, ts.ctx())
}
#[test]
fun test_successful_swap() {
let mut ts = ts::begin(@0x0);
// Bob locks the object they want to trade.
let (i2, ik2) = {
ts.next_tx(BOB);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
let cid = object::id(&c);
let (l, k) = lock::lock(c, ts.ctx());
let kid = object::id(&k);
transfer::public_transfer(l, BOB);
transfer::public_transfer(k, BOB);
(cid, kid)
};
// Alice creates a public Escrow holding the object they are willing to
// share, and the object they want from Bob
let i1 = {
ts.next_tx(ALICE);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
let cid = object::id(&c);
create(c, ik2, BOB, ts.ctx());
cid
};
// Bob responds by offering their object, and gets Alice's object in
// return.
{
ts.next_tx(BOB);
let escrow: Escrow<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_shared();
let k2: Key = ts.take_from_sender();
let l2: Locked<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_from_sender();
let c = escrow.swap(k2, l2, ts.ctx());
transfer::public_transfer(c, BOB);
};
// Commit effects from the swap
ts.next_tx(@0x0);
// Alice gets the object from Bob
{
let c: Coin<SUI> = ts.take_from_address_by_id(ALICE, i2);
ts::return_to_address(ALICE, c);
};
// Bob gets the object from Alice
{
let c: Coin<SUI> = ts.take_from_address_by_id(BOB, i1);
ts::return_to_address(BOB, c);
};
ts::end(ts);
}
#[test]
#[expected_failure(abort_code = EMismatchedSenderRecipient)]
fun test_mismatch_sender() {
let mut ts = ts::begin(@0x0);
let ik2 = {
ts.next_tx(DIANE);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
let (l, k) = lock::lock(c, ts.ctx());
let kid = object::id(&k);
transfer::public_transfer(l, DIANE);
transfer::public_transfer(k, DIANE);
kid
};
// Alice wants to trade with Bob.
{
ts.next_tx(ALICE);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
create(c, ik2, BOB, ts.ctx());
};
// But Diane is the one who attempts the swap
{
ts.next_tx(DIANE);
let escrow: Escrow<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_shared();
let k2: Key = ts.take_from_sender();
let l2: Locked<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_from_sender();
let c = escrow.swap(k2, l2, ts.ctx());
transfer::public_transfer(c, DIANE);
};
abort 1337
}
#[test]
#[expected_failure(abort_code = EMismatchedExchangeObject)]
fun test_mismatch_object() {
let mut ts = ts::begin(@0x0);
{
ts.next_tx(BOB);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
let (l, k) = lock::lock(c, ts.ctx());
transfer::public_transfer(l, BOB);
transfer::public_transfer(k, BOB);
};
// Alice wants to trade with Bob, but Alice has asked for an object (via
// its `exchange_key`) that Bob has not put up for the swap.
{
ts.next_tx(ALICE);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
let cid = object::id(&c);
create(c, cid, BOB, ts.ctx());
};
// When Bob tries to complete the swap, it will fail, because they
// cannot meet Alice's requirements.
{
ts.next_tx(BOB);
let escrow: Escrow<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_shared();
let k2: Key = ts.take_from_sender();
let l2: Locked<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_from_sender();
let c = escrow.swap(k2, l2, ts.ctx());
transfer::public_transfer(c, BOB);
};
abort 1337
}
#[test]
#[expected_failure(abort_code = EMismatchedExchangeObject)]
fun test_object_tamper() {
let mut ts = ts::begin(@0x0);
// Bob locks their object.
let ik2 = {
ts.next_tx(BOB);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
let (l, k) = lock::lock(c, ts.ctx());
let kid = object::id(&k);
transfer::public_transfer(l, BOB);
transfer::public_transfer(k, BOB);
kid
};
// Alice sets up the escrow
{
ts.next_tx(ALICE);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
create(c, ik2, BOB, ts.ctx());
};
// Bob has a change of heart, so they unlock the object and tamper with
// it before initiating the swap, but it won't be possible for Bob to
// hide their tampering.
{
ts.next_tx(BOB);
let k: Key = ts.take_from_sender();
let l: Locked<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_from_sender();
let mut c = lock::unlock(l, k);
let _dust = c.split(1, ts.ctx());
let (l, k) = lock::lock(c, ts.ctx());
let escrow: Escrow<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_shared();
let c = escrow.swap(k, l, ts.ctx());
transfer::public_transfer(c, BOB);
};
abort 1337
}
#[test]
fun test_return_to_sender() {
let mut ts = ts::begin(@0x0);
// Alice puts up the object they want to trade
let cid = {
ts.next_tx(ALICE);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
let cid = object::id(&c);
let i = object::id_from_address(@0x0);
create(c, i, BOB, ts.ctx());
cid
};
// ...but has a change of heart and takes it back
{
ts.next_tx(ALICE);
let escrow: Escrow<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_shared();
let c = escrow.return_to_sender(ts.ctx());
transfer::public_transfer(c, ALICE);
};
ts.next_tx(@0x0);
// Alice can then access it.
{
let c: Coin<SUI> = ts.take_from_address_by_id(ALICE, cid);
ts::return_to_address(ALICE, c)
};
ts::end(ts);
}
#[test]
#[expected_failure]
fun test_return_to_sender_failed_swap() {
let mut ts = ts::begin(@0x0);
// Bob locks their object.
let ik2 = {
ts.next_tx(BOB);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
let (l, k) = lock::lock(c, ts.ctx());
let kid = object::id(&k);
transfer::public_transfer(l, BOB);
transfer::public_transfer(k, BOB);
kid
};
// Alice creates a public Escrow holding the object they are willing to
// share, and the object they want from Bob
{
ts.next_tx(ALICE);
let c = test_coin(&mut ts);
create(c, ik2, BOB, ts.ctx());
};
// ...but then has a change of heart
{
ts.next_tx(ALICE);
let escrow: Escrow<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_shared();
let c = escrow.return_to_sender(ts.ctx());
transfer::public_transfer(c, ALICE);
};
// Bob's attempt to complete the swap will now fail.
{
ts.next_tx(BOB);
let escrow: Escrow<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_shared();
let k2: Key = ts.take_from_sender();
let l2: Locked<Coin<SUI>> = ts.take_from_sender();
let c = escrow.swap(k2, l2, ts.ctx());
transfer::public_transfer(c, BOB);
};
abort 1337
}
}
The protocol in the shared object case is less symmetric, but still starts with the first party locking the object they want to swap.
The second party can then view the object that was locked, and if they decide they want to swap with it, they indicate their interest by creating a swap request:
public fun create<T: key + store>(
escrowed: T,
exchange_key: ID,
recipient: address,
ctx: &mut TxContext
) {
let mut escrow = Escrow<T> {
id: object::new(ctx),
sender: ctx.sender(),
recipient,
exchange_key,
};
event::emit(EscrowCreated {
escrow_id: object::id(&escrow),
key_id: exchange_key,
sender: escrow.sender,
recipient,
item_id: object::id(&escrowed),
});
dof::add(&mut escrow.id, EscrowedObjectKey {}, escrowed);
transfer::public_share_object(escrow);
}
This time the create request accepts the object being escrowed directly (not locked), and creates a shared Escrow object. The request remembers the address that sent it (who is allowed to reclaim the object if the swap hasn't already happened), and the intended recipient, who is then expected to continue the swap by providing the object they initially locked:
/// The `recipient` of the escrow can exchange `obj` with the escrowed item
public fun swap<T: key + store, U: key + store>(
mut escrow: Escrow<T>,
key: Key,
locked: Locked<U>,
ctx: &TxContext,
): T {
let escrowed = dof::remove<EscrowedObjectKey, T>(&mut escrow.id, EscrowedObjectKey {});
let Escrow {
id,
sender,
recipient,
exchange_key,
} = escrow;
assert!(recipient == ctx.sender(), EMismatchedSenderRecipient);
assert!(exchange_key == object::id(&key), EMismatchedExchangeObject);
// Do the actual swap
transfer::public_transfer(locked.unlock(key), sender);
event::emit(EscrowSwapped {
escrow_id: id.to_inner(),
});
id.delete();
escrowed
}
Even though the Escrow object is a shared object that is accessible by anyone, the Move interface ensures that only the original sender and the intended recipient can successfully interact with it. swap checks that the locked object matches the object that was requested when the Escrow was created (again, by comparing key IDs) and assumes that the intended recipient wants the escrowed object (if they did not, they would not have called swap).
Assuming all checks pass, the object held in Escrow is extracted, its wrapper is deleted and it is returned to the first party. The locked object offered by the first party is also unlocked and sent to the second party, completing the swap.
Comparison
This topic explores two ways to implement a swap between two objects. In both cases there is a point at which one party has made a request and the other has not responded. At this point, both parties may want to access the Escrow object: One to cancel the swap, and the other to complete it.
In one case, the protocol uses only owned objects but requires a custodian to act as an intermediary. This has the advantage of avoiding the costs and latencies of consensus altogether, but involves more steps and requires trusting a third party for liveness.
In the other case, the object is custodied on chain in a shared object. This requires consensus but involves fewer steps, and no third party.